Bernoulli Drives needed in working condition
This thread and subject-matter, seems to me to be "much ado about nothing". Sorry. But there is so. much. chatter. about this Bernoulli drive and cartridge business, reasonable people can't keep their focus on *what the tasks are*, what is reasonable to do, and unreasonable to do, and by whom. This caught my attention, because I likely have a clue about this tech. http://www.retrotechnology.com/aux/iomega10.html Are these the 'droids you are looking for? Note: I'm in the process NOW of selling the drive. I may have some IBM controllers available. I'm not giving them away, this is stuff I sell. That's not exactly why I posted. So: what is all this chatter about, and what seems a plausible path forward? First: the propositions, as stated by Jeff Brace:
Someone donated two 10x10 Bernoulli drives to VCF. They are in unknown condition. She gave us the manual, a cable and one cartridge. She wants to donate the remaining cartridges, but would like to supervise the deletion of the data they have on them. So we need one in working condition first.
and:
It is payroll data that the couple used for their business for many years, so it is quite sensitive. First: this appears to be a legal contract over property and services. Not that I'm a lawyer. VCFed Incorporated may wish to examine these terms, as Dave McGuire pointed out, and see if the Corporation wishes to engage in such contracts with clients. Hint. Hint.
Second: how many carts is this about, anyways? Ebay price - by luck I happened to look recently - some tens of dollars each. Point being: why spin all our wheels, just over a few carts? And: *are there any in the VCFed Inventory already*? Just a thought. Related: "two 10X10 drives" is ambiguous. Is it one cabinet with two drives, as per my unit? That's my guess, and I show an example. Third: I see no "data recovery" in these terms, as suggested in the chatter. Just data security. So: let the client keep the carts, if they choose to destroy them, that would be sad. But that solves the problem, no. further. fuss. needed. That's my recommendation. If there are objections: 1) Google "who bells the cat?" Hint: it's about finding volunteers for difficult tasks. 2) Google "the lady who put salt in her coffee". Old-person alert - this is 19th century technology. It's about solving problems. 3) - if you think YOU can make this work, convince Jeff Brace and the corporation, and that you can execute on it. I won't touch that, myself. I don't make that offer. 4) - if you think more 10MB carts are important - buy some off eBay. Or donate $$$ to VCFed Inc and they can buy them. Myself: I'll consider it, depending on what becomes of this donation, and my own sale of my drive (if that's the drive in question). So here's my specific advice, since I'm posting so much already. Tell the donor: "Thank you for the donation of the drive equipment and the single disk cartridge. Unfortunately, we are not in the business of data destruction and deletion. And we will not be able to operate the drive anytime in the near future: our resources to restore and operate equipment are voluntary and limited; it needs a controller we would have to acquire. "So we are not able to satisfy your terms of assured data destruction; so we cannot accept your data cartridges. If we become aware of such services, we'll provide you with contact information as a courtesy, for your own considerations. Thank you again for helping us in our goals of preserving vintage computing technology." This solves all problems, with no additional resources of time, money, materials or performance by individuals or VCFed Inc.. And that is my contribution to the discussion. That, and a link to what I think may be similar tech. At some point soon in time, I may add IBM controller information to my Bernoulli Web page. That may be useful for information. If VCFed has some interest in items I have, they or their donors can contact me for prices. Those items are untested, as-is, without warranty or fitness for use. Regards, Herb Johnson retrotechnology.com -- Herbert R. Johnson, New Jersey in the USA http://www.retrotechnology.com OR .net preserve, recover, restore 1970's computing email: hjohnson AT retrotechnology DOT com or try later herbjohnson AT comcast DOT net
On 5/18/21 4:53 PM, Herb Johnson via vcf-midatlantic wrote:
This thread and subject-matter, seems to me to be "much ado about nothing". Sorry. But there is so. much. chatter. about this Bernoulli drive and cartridge business, reasonable people can't keep their focus on *what the tasks are*, what is reasonable to do, and unreasonable to do, and by whom.
This is a mailing list populated by a few hundred people with similar interests. Chatter happens. This time, however, it was all on-topic and directly related to the original query. It was not "chatter", it was relevant discussion that resulted in the sharing of knowledge and the answering of questions. In fact, thus far, it has been one of the highest signal/noise ratio threads to take place on this mailing list in a very long time. Sorry buddy, I call 'em as I see 'em.
Third: I see no "data recovery" in these terms, as suggested in the chatter. Just data security. So: let the client keep the carts, if they choose to destroy them, that would be sad. But that solves the problem, no. further. fuss. needed. That's my recommendation.
The end result of that would likely be the cartridges eventually being destroyed. I shouldn't have to explain why that would be bad, but: These haven't been made in decades, people want them, and they are rapidly becoming difficult to find. In other words, save as many as you can. Help donors retrieve and/or destroy their data if that's what's required. Yes, occasionally there's actual WORK involved in what we do. Work is not the enemy. If you're going to suggest shying away from a few Bernoulli disks, what will happen if someone shows up with an IBM 3380E? -Dave -- Dave McGuire, AK4HZ New Kensington, PA
<jeffrey@vcfed.org> On Tue, May 18, 2021 at 5:06 PM Herb Johnson via vcf-midatlantic < vcf-midatlantic@lists.vcfed.org> wrote:
This caught my attention, because I likely have a clue about this tech.
http://www.retrotechnology.com/aux/iomega10.html
Are these the 'droids you are looking for?
Yes! They are the droids that I'm looking for! And FYI: Jedi mind tricks don't work with me ;)
First: the propositions, as stated by Jeff Brace:
Someone donated two 10x10 Bernoulli drives to VCF. They are in unknown condition. She gave us the manual, a cable and one cartridge. She wants to donate the remaining cartridges, but would like to supervise the deletion of the data they have on them. So we need one in working condition first.
and:
It is payroll data that the couple used for their business for many years, so it is quite sensitive. First: this appears to be a legal contract over property and services. Not that I'm a lawyer. VCFed Incorporated may wish to examine these terms, as Dave McGuire pointed out, and see if the Corporation wishes to engage in such contracts with clients. Hint. Hint.
Yes, Dave gave us some contract and we are looking to use it out of an abundance of caution.
Second: how many carts is this about, anyways? Ebay price - by luck I happened to look recently - some tens of dollars each. Point being: why spin all our wheels, just over a few carts? And: *are there any in the VCFed Inventory already*? Just a thought.
There are about 30 to 40 cartridges, maybe 50. I had them give me one for testing purposes because I'm pretty certain that VCF *doesn't* have any of these. Tony and the Inventory Committee would know better than me, but I have never seen any in the warehouse. Related: "two 10X10 drives" is ambiguous. Is it one cabinet with two
drives, as per my unit? That's my guess, and I show an example.
It is two cabinets with two drives per unit. So two units like the one that you have. One is labeled "working", but who knows when it was last working.
Third: I see no "data recovery" in these terms, as suggested in the chatter. Just data security. So: let the client keep the carts, if they choose to destroy them, that would be sad. But that solves the problem, no. further. fuss. needed. That's my recommendation.
She wanted to destroy the cartridges. I didn't have time to research how rare they were, so I asked if we could have them. Then she said that there was payroll data that she wanted deleted. She wanted to go through the data herself and delete it herself once we got the drives working. ========================================= Jeff Brace Vice President & Board Member Vintage Computer Festival East Show-runner Vintage Computer Federation is a 501c3 charity http://www.vcfed.org/ jeffrey@vcfed.org
I can never figure out why people take fuzzy blurry pictures and post them. Sent from: My extremely complicated, hand held electronic device.
On May 18, 2021, at 9:41 PM, Jeffrey Brace via vcf-midatlantic <vcf-midatlantic@lists.vcfed.org> wrote:
<jeffrey@vcfed.org>
On Tue, May 18, 2021 at 5:06 PM Herb Johnson via vcf-midatlantic < vcf-midatlantic@lists.vcfed.org> wrote:
This caught my attention, because I likely have a clue about this tech.
http://www.retrotechnology.com/aux/iomega10.html
Are these the 'droids you are looking for?
Yes! They are the droids that I'm looking for! And FYI: Jedi mind tricks don't work with me ;)
First: the propositions, as stated by Jeff Brace:
Someone donated two 10x10 Bernoulli drives to VCF. They are in unknown condition. She gave us the manual, a cable and one cartridge. She wants to donate the remaining cartridges, but would like to supervise the deletion of the data they have on them. So we need one in working condition first.
and:
It is payroll data that the couple used for their business for many years, so it is quite sensitive. First: this appears to be a legal contract over property and services. Not that I'm a lawyer. VCFed Incorporated may wish to examine these terms, as Dave McGuire pointed out, and see if the Corporation wishes to engage in such contracts with clients. Hint. Hint.
Yes, Dave gave us some contract and we are looking to use it out of an abundance of caution.
Second: how many carts is this about, anyways? Ebay price - by luck I happened to look recently - some tens of dollars each. Point being: why spin all our wheels, just over a few carts? And: *are there any in the VCFed Inventory already*? Just a thought.
There are about 30 to 40 cartridges, maybe 50. I had them give me one for testing purposes because I'm pretty certain that VCF *doesn't* have any of these. Tony and the Inventory Committee would know better than me, but I have never seen any in the warehouse.
Related: "two 10X10 drives" is ambiguous. Is it one cabinet with two
drives, as per my unit? That's my guess, and I show an example.
It is two cabinets with two drives per unit. So two units like the one that you have. One is labeled "working", but who knows when it was last working.
Third: I see no "data recovery" in these terms, as suggested in the chatter. Just data security. So: let the client keep the carts, if they choose to destroy them, that would be sad. But that solves the problem, no. further. fuss. needed. That's my recommendation.
She wanted to destroy the cartridges. I didn't have time to research how rare they were, so I asked if we could have them. Then she said that there was payroll data that she wanted deleted. She wanted to go through the data herself and delete it herself once we got the drives working.
========================================= Jeff Brace Vice President & Board Member Vintage Computer Festival East Show-runner Vintage Computer Federation is a 501c3 charity http://www.vcfed.org/ jeffrey@vcfed.org
participants (4)
-
Dave McGuire -
Herb Johnson -
Jeffrey Brace -
Sentrytv